Skip to content

Extract backend-neutral font measurement so DOCX and PPTX stop depending on render-pdf #441

Open

Description

@DemchaAV

Opening a DocumentSession resolves a FontMetricsProvider so text can be measured, and graph-compose-render-pdf is the only artifact that publishes one. Two consequences reach consumers today:

DOCX is not installable on its own. render-docx/pom.xml declares render-pdf at test scope — enough for the module's own suite, which builds a session to exercise the exporter. A consumer who installs graph-compose-core + graph-compose-render-docx fails at create() with MissingBackendException before any export runs. Surfaced by the new s8-core-render-docx release-smoke scenario, which is why that scenario pins core + render-docx + render-pdf. Documented as a requirement in render-docx/README.md for 2.1.0.

PPTX drags in the whole PDF stack. render-pptx declares render-pdf at compile scope deliberately — it reuses the PDF font-measurement library so glyph widths stay aligned with the widths that produced the layout graph, and it re-renders through the PDF backend for the clip raster fallback. The measurement half of that coupling is not inherent; the raster half is. So "install exactly what you render" is not fully true for either POI backend.

Extracting the font-measurement seam into its own artifact (or shipping a default provider in core) would let a DOCX consumer install two coordinates and a PPTX consumer avoid PDFBox except when clipping actually rasterises.

Not a 2.1.0 blocker: both combinations work once the PDF backend is present, and that is now documented and covered by release smoke. Raising the dependency scope in render-docx was considered as a quick fix for 2.1.0 and rejected — it would widen every DOCX consumer's tree while leaving the underlying coupling in place.

Related: the roadmap's "Backend-neutral layout measurement" item.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions