QA run · records-forms (30/44) · 5b14b7f3 · 2026-10-19 · 11 PASS / 19 PARTIAL / 0 FAIL / 0 BLOCKED / 14 NOT-RUN #24572

Run record for the 18.0 release sweep, selector records-forms (resolved with node scripts/checklist-select.mjs area:records-forms --json), plan B (Tier 1 + Tier 2; Tier 3 deferred).

Environment fingerprint

• framework: 5b14b7f3ad8e2e0786d228772f473d07b36b2477 (objectstack-ai/objectstack main), working tree clean
• console: .objectui-sha = 4016370af3c9c9dafec2bc5299afd8e8079701b8, built with pnpm objectui:build; packages/console/dist/.objectui-sha stamp equals the pin (pnpm check:console-sha green), so the stale-console-bundle trap is ruled out for every console observation
• app: showcase (examples/app-showcase), canonical boot OS_PORT=PORT pnpm -C examples/app-showcase exec objectstack dev --ui --seed-admin -p PORT -d file:/tmp/qa18/ITEM/data.db; every hand-driven item had its own port and file DB (listed per item below); seed: --seed-admin (admin@objectos.ai) + showcase seed + per-item scratch fixtures
• Tier 1 pins: vitest per package against the same tree (pnpm exec vitest run FILES), 97 framework files / 2209 tests, 0 failed; objectui-side pins run inside a clone of objectui at 4016370af3c9 (unit vitest + playwright.live.config.ts against a showcase boot on :47431 through the objectui console dev server), RUNNER option (b)
• browser: Playwright with /opt/pw-browsers/chromium, own context per persona, sign-in through the form
• timestamps: 2026-10-19, environment prep 12:26–12:43 UTC, testing 12:43–13:53 UTC; Tier 2 items were driven in parallel by sub-runners (≤ 3–4 browser items at once), each on its own port/DB

Scope

Selector records-forms → 44 runnable item(s). Planned (not runnable, not counted): records-forms.picklist-shared-across-objects → planned. Blocked items hidden by the resolver were not run (no --include-blocked).

Tiering (checklist-test SKILL §1): Tier 1 = item carries automated.ref (pin run, cited); Tier 2 = unpinned P0/P1 (hand-driven); Tier 3 = unpinned P2 (deferred, not-run).

Per-clause verdicts

A = acceptance[n], N = negative[n]. Tier 1 rule: a clause is pass only when a passing pin covers it (server-side oracles, or clauses the ref names); clauses a ref says it does not cover, and UI-oracle clauses a server-side pin cannot see, are not-run. Evidence is text from the oracle — no images.

records-forms.crud-roundtrip — pass (hand-driven (port 47461 · file:/tmp/qa18/crud/data.db · hand-driven (the automated.ref pins only acceptance[6]'s readonly half)))

records-forms.field-type-matrix — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.list-view-capabilities — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.view-type-gallery — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.form-view-gallery — pass (hand-driven (port 47462 · file:/tmp/qa18/formgal/data.db))

records-forms.conditional-rules-header — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.conditional-rules-grid — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.cascading-options — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.master-detail-atomic-save — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.related-list-server-pagination — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.action-param-widgets — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.upload-guard-blocks-confirm — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.import-wizard-encoding-and-hints — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.action-location-matrix — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.validation-rule-type-matrix — partial (hand-driven (port 47403 · file:/tmp/qa18/vr-matrix/data.db))

records-forms.gantt-interactions — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.kanban-drag-persistence — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.form-dirty-guard — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.named-import-mapping — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.adhoc-filter-sort-builder — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.calendar-interactions — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.concurrent-edit-conflict — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.record-discussion-mentions — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.grid-personalization — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.saved-view-management — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.bulk-select-all-matching — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.lookup-picker-create-new — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.import-job-undo-cancel — not-run (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.object-hook-lifecycle — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.field-type-constraints — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.cascading-multilevel-and-clear — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.encrypted-field-behavior — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.field-group-visible-when — pass (hand-driven (port 47463 · file:/tmp/qa18/fgvw/data.db · scratch package com.objectstack.qa.groupgate, object qa_group_gate))

records-forms.field-unique-enforcement — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.delete-behavior-matrix — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.record-clone-contract — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.field-history-tracking — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.import-transform-matrix — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.predicate-relationship-traversal — partial (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.script-action-hook-refusal-toast — not-run (Tier 3)

records-forms.write-time-option-and-element-shape-judgement — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.write-answer-advisories-rollback-and-tree-delete — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.comment-reactions-and-edit-stamps — pass (Tier 1 pin)

records-forms.v18-semantic-defaults — partial (Tier 1 pin)

Reproduction rules

No clause scored fail in this selector. One negative recorded a contract drift that its own text asks to be filed:

records-forms.field-group-visible-when · negative[2] — a faulting field-group visibleWhen renders the section (fail-OPEN) while the spec declares fail-CLOSED

1. Boot the canonical showcase. As admin create a writable package (POST /api/v1/packages with a manifest) and an object in it with one field group whose visibleWhen faults — e.g. "record.no_such_field == 'x'" (unknown field) or "record.kind ==" (syntax-broken): PUT /api/v1/meta/object/qa_group_gate?package=PKG → 200 (both shapes accepted at authoring).
2. Publish, create a record, open its edit form (/record/ID/edit) and its detail page.
3. Actual: the group's section (header + members) is SHOWN on both surfaces; the browser console logs [object-ui] A conditional predicate failed to evaluate (visibleWhen of group 'pro_details' …) and was treated as its safe default (true) … [parse] Unexpected token: EOF. No blank form, no crash (the clause's FAIL shape did not occur).
4. Declared contract: packages/spec/src/data/object.zod.ts ObjectFieldGroupSchema.visibleWhen describe — "the whole group (header included) is shown only when TRUE, else hidden (fail-closed)"; ADR-0137's scope note names this slot as carrying its OWN declared fail-closed direction, distinct from the field-rule triad's render fail-open (ADR-0137 D3).

• Disposition: product defect against the declared contract (renderer half in objectui). Extracted at close-out. The negative itself scores pass (no blank/crash); the direction is recorded, not ticked.

Derived item verdicts

11 pass · 19 partial · 14 not-run. The P0 records-forms.crud-roundtrip was hand-driven in full and passed (its pin covers only half of acceptance[6]). Partials are Tier 1 items whose pins (framework vitest or objectui at 4016370a) cover part of the clauses — uncovered clauses are not-run rows above — plus validation-rule-type-matrix (N0 needs an unevaluable rule that stock cannot author).

Checklist-accuracy findings / fixture gaps (for the wave anchor card)

• objectui live specs red against their own same-sha console (4016370a), all stale-spec, none a product defect: user-filters.spec.ts :22/:43/:128 assert pre-ADR-0053 showcase metadata (status presets moved to named views; six visualizations incl. timeline) and :73 uses a cell locator where the grid exposes gridcell; form-view-subforms.spec.ts and grid-file-upload.spec.ts collide in strict mode with the sr-only DialogDescription; field-conditional-rules.spec.ts expects a disabled input where the UI renders read-only text; cascading-options.spec.ts:51 expects md-form-submit on a flat ModalForm; detail-related-list.spec.ts waits for ?recordId= where a row click now opens /record/ID; inline-edit-polish-2572.spec.ts expects the approval-locked path but manager_review is deliberately lockRecord: false, and it consumes its fixture (needs a fresh DB). Under the objectui Vite dev server several specs need more than the default 30 s budget (timing, not product).
• Pins that exercise none of their item's clauses: calendar-interactions (geometry via callback only), grid-personalization, lookup-picker-create-new (adjacent, as its ref admits), action-param-widgets' objectui half (action-modal.spec.ts has no params); list-row-action-cel.spec.ts is too weak for action-location-matrix A3 / conditional-rules-header A4; record-history-display.spec.ts needs an app-todo backend and always skips against showcase; concurrent-edit-conflict's occSave unit pin covers client halves only. import-job-undo-cancel's import-console / import-harness specs were not run this sweep.
• records-forms.list-view-capabilities: its framework ref showcase-search.dogfood.test.ts is search-scoped; no list-view clause is attributable to it.
• records-forms.crud-roundtrip: acceptance[6]'s cloner-ownership half needs a non-owner cloner (an admin cloning an admin row cannot tell the two apart; showcase_field_zoo + the contributor member also covers autonumber and formula); negative[2] names status but the required-no-default field on showcase_account is name. objectui observations: History renders the currency diff unformatted (4200000); after a RecordFormPage edit save a direct load lands on /_console/home.
• records-forms.form-view-gallery: the revert door is DELETE /api/v1/meta/view/NAME (resets the overlay byte-identically); the named variants are served as their own view items showcase_task.{tabbed,wizard,split,quick}.
• records-forms.field-group-visible-when: authoring accepts a syntactically invalid CEL visibleWhen (record.kind ==) with 200 — no parse-time check on this slot; the grouped section renders above the ungrouped fields; the item cites objectui 1fb1ced36243 as the pin, now 4016370af3c9.
• records-forms.validation-rule-type-matrix: fixtures call account_lifecycle the state-machine specimen but it binds update only — invalid_initial_state comes from project_status_flow alone; negative[0] needs an unevaluable-CEL rule that stock cannot author (fixture gap).
• records-forms.picklist-shared-across-objects — planned (not run, not counted).

Hand-off (items without a judged verdict)

• Tier 3 deferred by the 18.0 release-sweep plan (not-run): upload-guard-blocks-confirm, kanban-drag-persistence, named-import-mapping, saved-view-management, import-transform-matrix, script-action-hook-refusal-toast (all P2).
• Tier 1 items whose pin covered no whole clause and that were not hand-driven this run (not-run): related-list-server-pagination, action-location-matrix, adhoc-filter-sort-builder, calendar-interactions, concurrent-edit-conflict (P1); grid-personalization, lookup-picker-create-new, import-job-undo-cancel (P2).
• Partial items' uncovered clauses are listed per item above (not-run rows).

Generated by Claude Code